Papey Island itself is a living bucket list: thousands of Atlantic puffins nest here alongside eider ducks, grey seals, and Iceland's oldest wooden church. A private charter puts you ashore where most tourists never set foot.
What to expect
The 20-minute crossing from Djúpivogur harbour already rewards with harbour porpoise sightings and dramatic views of the Eastfjords. Landing on Papey, your naturalist guide leads you along soft clifftop paths where puffins nest just metres away, entirely unbothered by slow, quiet visitors. The island's tiny 1807 church and lighthouse are photogenic beyond belief. Grey seals haul out on nearby skerries, often visible from the boat on the return crossing.
Good to know
Season runs June–August, peaking in July when pufflings are most active. Since Papey is privately owned, a guided tour is the only legal access — do not attempt independent landing. Confirm your ship's tender schedule with the operator; tours typically run 3–4 hours total. Waterproof layers and grip-sole footwear are essential.